Kent's Police Commissioner Urges PM to Drop Plans for Nine 'Mega Forces'

Kent's Police and Crime Commissioner, Matthew Scott, has co-ordinated an open letter to the Prime Minister urging him to abandon proposals to merge England's 43 police forces into as few as nine. The letter, published on 16 November, is backed by 31 Police and Crime Commissioners, Police, Fire and Crime Commissioners and Deputy Mayors from across the country.

What's being proposed

The idea of consolidating the 43 forces into between eight and ten larger, regional "mega forces" was first tabled by the Home Secretary in January this year.
It's been pushed heavily by Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley and the National Police Chiefs' Council. Rowley believes the move would help fight organised crime by pooling resources, which he says would also keep costs down.

The scale of the change

43
police forces in England & Wales today
→
8-10
regional "mega forces" proposed
A report from Lord Hogan-Howe on how the mergers could work is due before Christmas, though no date has been set; legislation is expected to follow in early 2027.

Timeline - what happens next

1
January 2026
The Home Secretary first tables the idea of merging England's 43 police forces into fewer, larger regional forces.
2
5 November 2026
Scott issues a statement opposing mergers ahead of a Metropolitan Police-organised panel on the subject in Manchester.
3
16 November 2026
Matthew Scott and 31 other PCCs, PFCCs and Deputy Mayors publish their joint open letter opposing the plans.
4
Before Christmas 2026 (exact date tbc)
Lord Hogan-Howe's report on how the mergers could work is due to be published.
5
Early 2027
Legislation to implement any merger plan is expected to follow.

Scott's been making this case for weeks

The joint letter isn't Scott's first word on this. On 5 November, the day before Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley and a group of other chiefs were due to discuss force mergers at a Met-organised panel in Manchester, Scott put out his own statement.
In it, he said there was "no evidence that bigger forces will mean less crime and fewer victims," arguing that "the academic evidence instead points to larger forces being less efficient and effective" - and pointed to recent HMICFRS and Baroness Casey inspections of the Met as showing that "the culture in mega forces is not something policing should be seeking to export."
He also warned that "rural communities will certainly suffer as policing will retreat to cities under this mega force model," and that officers and staff would be "taken away from frontline duties to work on these uncosted and unfunded proposals when they should be catching criminals not completing spreadsheets."
On the question of democratic mandate, he said the proposals weren't in any manifesto and hadn't been put to public consultation, adding: "Decisions about local policing will be made further and further away from where policing matters most - in local communities and neighbourhoods." Source: Office of the Kent Police and Crime Commissioner.

Kent's objection

Scott says the public hasn't been properly consulted, and that a reorganisation on this scale would cause a decade of disruption - including pulling officers away from local neighbourhood duties.
In the letter, he writes: "The consequences for our local neighbourhoods, victims and witnesses will be substantial and we are concerned about the disruption that force mergers will cause for local policing, investigations and accountability. The creation of nine regional forces would mean a council tax increase for millions of people as precepts will have to be aligned. During a cost-of-living crisis, should residents be expected to pay more to merge police forces, for what for many will mean less of a service?"
He also argues the change would clash with the Government's own devolution plans, warning it risks "all of the benefits of devolution for public safety, policing and the wider criminal justice system lost."
Scott has also sought the views of Kent residents directly on the proposals: 83% came back opposed to force mergers, though more than half said they hadn't been aware of the plans before being asked.

What Kent residents told the Commissioner

Oppose force mergers
83%
All other responses
17%

Separately - awareness of the plans

Hadn't heard of the plans before being asked
50%+

Source: figures cited by the Kent Police and Crime Commissioner in the 16 November letter.

"Not performing functions 43 times"

The letter pushes back on the idea that having 43 separate forces is inherently inefficient, pointing to existing national collaborations it says are already delivering savings without a full merger: "The often-repeated argument that policing is performing certain functions 43 times is incorrect. We have mature and established regional and national collaborations which are delivering better investigations and outcomes for our neighbourhoods. BlueLight Commercial and Police Digital Service, both companies owned by PCCs and Deputy Mayors, have delivered millions of pounds of savings and efficiencies since their establishment."
Scott added: "The evidence does not support a nine-force model for policing. The public does not support it. Mayors and PCCs do not support it. Many Chief Constables do not support it... We urge you to intervene to stop the top-down re-organisation of police forces."
This is a separate issue from the Government's plan, already announced, to abolish the Police and Crime Commissioner role itself by 2028 - that's about who holds the police to account locally, while this letter is about whether Kent Police would keep existing as its own force at all. Source: Office of the Kent Police and Crime Commissioner.